Thursday, May 5, 2011

[Ranking] Top 10 JC staff animation


Here is ranking for top JC Staff animation, by biglobe survey.

  1. Tantai Opera Milky Holmes
  2. Taisho Yakuu Musume
  3. Toradora!
  4. To Aru Kagaku no Railgun
  5. Aoi Hana
  6. To Aru Majutsu no Index
  7. Otome Yokai Zakuro
  8. Hidan no Aria
  9. Yumekui Merry
  10. Shakugan no Shana
  11. ROD
  12. Kaichou wa Maid-sama!
  13. Zero no Tsukaima
  14. Azumanga Daioh
  15. Okami-san to Shinchinin no Nakamatachi
My opinion:

- Totally agree with Tentai Opera Milky Holmes. Easily the best thing they've made. Though, I would have Azumanga Daioh above it.
-Taisho Yakuu Musume is a troll.
- Toradora! is on 3rd, very convincing.
-Railgun Index.... Thus Misaka > Indexuu
-Aoi Hana's getting good reception, obviously.
- A lot of new-released animation on the list, which pretty much all failed. Yumekui Merry? Hidan no Aria?... meh.
- Kugimiya Rie series lol


  1. Kinda lame that Azumanga Daioh is so far down on the list.

  2. This fails so hard, mostly just recent shit. This list could have 15 amazing shows. Would make my own list but it'd take forever.

  3. @myswordisunbelievablydull:

    Recent shit? Are you implying that Milky Holmes shit?... Oh hell, in my opinion, that was one of the best animation that JC Staff ever made since Toradora. Everything else is all so-so level, so it is not even worth comparing.

  4. Cant really enjoy Milky Holmes...
    I think its stupid imo.
    I mean... i wished they were little bit smarter :P

    I like Taisho Yakyuu Musume.
    It was nice seeing old japanese environment and cute girls :P

    And wow Aoi Hana is on the list..
    I heard it wont get 2nd season due the dvd sale poorly

  5. @Anon: Milky Holmes is a model-example for any comedy show with no tsukomi. Everyone is Boke, so we need to become tsukomi by ourselves. In order to do that, some well timed direction and well written dialogs must be supported. MH did that, fancifully but convincingly.

  6. This is BS because they splitted the Honey and Clover into two. Also what the hell happened to Nodame and Azumanga?

    Seeing Merry there is a bit weird too.